Saturday, November 21, 2026 · Vail, Colorado SearchSubscribe

Vail's Independent Newspaper


Brush Creek Valley Ranch Open Space, the 1,671 acre Eagle County property south of Eagle on Brush Creek Road, in an aerial photograph published by Eagle County. It is one of three Eagle County properties named in the proposed state rule.
Brush Creek Valley Ranch Open Space, the 1,671 acre Eagle County property south of Eagle on Brush Creek Road, in an aerial photograph published by Eagle County. It is one of three Eagle County properties named in the proposed state rule. Photo: Todd Winslow Pierce, via Eagle County

EAGLE COUNTY

A proposed state rule would let wildlife officers enforce hunting closures on three Eagle County open spaces

Colorado Parks and Wildlife opened the proposal at its Nov. 4-5 commission meeting. Today, a person caught hunting on county land that Eagle County has closed generally faces only a county citation of $50 to $100, and keeps the animal. The draft rule would add state charges, license points and possible seizure.

Colorado Parks and Wildlife has opened a rulemaking that would let state wildlife officers enforce hunting, fishing and trapping closures on three Eagle County open spaces: Brush Creek Valley Ranch Open Space, Red Dirt Creek Open Space and Duck Pond River Access Open Space. The Parks and Wildlife Commission took up the proposal as item 12 on the agenda of its Nov. 4-5 meeting in Fort Morgan, the first step of a two step review, and published its meeting recap on Nov. 12. The question before the commission, from the staff issue paper dated Oct. 23, is whether lands that Eagle County, Larimer County and the City of Fort Collins manage, and have closed under their own rules or ordinances, should also be closed to hunting, fishing and trapping under a state regulation.

A county citation with no teeth behind it

Elk on Brush Creek Valley Ranch, in a photograph published by Eagle County. The county allows hunting on the property only in special hunts accompanied by Colorado Parks and Wildlife staff.
Elk on Brush Creek Valley Ranch, in a photograph published by Eagle County. The county allows hunting on the property only in special hunts accompanied by Colorado Parks and Wildlife staff. Photo: Todd Winslow Pierce, via Eagle County

The issue paper explains the gap the rule is meant to close. Colorado's trespass statute, section 33-6-116(1) of the Colorado Revised Statutes, covers private property and not government owned land, so a person caught hunting on county open space that the county has closed generally faces only a county citation, typically a fine of $50 to $100. State wildlife officers have no authority to take enforcement action or seize an illegally harvested animal over a city or county ordinance violation. A county citation also carries no hunting or fishing privilege points, and no weight in a license suspension hearing or under the Interstate Wildlife Violator Compact, which covers 49 of the 50 states. The paper says district wildlife managers have struggled to enforce the closures, that local sheriffs are frustrated, and that land managers, county commissioners and sheriff's offices in Eagle and Larimer counties asked the agency to find a solution.

What the draft rule would change

The Eagle River at Minturn, in a file photograph. The proposed rule also names Duck Pond River Access Open Space, one of the county's river access properties, and Red Dirt Creek Open Space.
The Eagle River at Minturn, in a file photograph. The proposed rule also names Duck Pond River Access Open Space, one of the county's river access properties, and Red Dirt Creek Open Space. Photo: Jeffrey Beall / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The staff recommendation is a regulation, drafted as section 004 G of Chapter W-0, covering listed lands closed by ordinance to hunting, fishing and trapping and posted accordingly. Its operative sentence reads:

It is unlawful for any person to hunt, fish, or trap wildlife on these lands without first obtaining written permission from the relevant municipality.

Draft rule text, CPW issue paper, item 12

With a state rule in place, the paper says, an officer who finds a clear case of accidental entry could choose a written warning or a citation, while an intentional case, the paper's example is a hunter who kills a trophy bull elk on closed land, could draw the new regulatory charge, a citation for illegal possession of wildlife, a possible Samson surcharge, suspension of hunting and fishing privileges, and seizure and forfeiture of the animal, none of which is available today. The agency proposes the listed properties, which it says have a history of violations, as a pilot, with other properties considered case by case, and says the rule would not apply to a person passing through city or county land to hunt or fish on adjacent land. Staff are still working with the counties on the specific property descriptions and maps the final rule will carry.

The Eagle County ground at stake

The largest of the three local properties is Brush Creek Valley Ranch Open Space, 1,671 acres south of the town of Eagle on Brush Creek Road, owned by Eagle County under a conservation easement held by the Eagle Valley Land Trust. The county's own page for the property states that hunting is not allowed there except for special hunts accompanied by Parks and Wildlife staff, run for herd management, a mentor program, disabled veterans and game damage, and that hunters may pass through the ranch on three named trails to reach adjacent Bureau of Land Management and national forest land. Eagle County restated its open space rules and regulations in Resolution 2024-033, adopted May 2, 2024. The issue paper lists the Eagle County Sheriff's Department among the stakeholders advised, and records their feedback as supportive. The same item also proposes extending the S44 bighorn sheep unit boundary to include areas the herd uses on the north side of Red Table Mountain. A second step of commission review is still required before any rule is adopted, and the agency takes public comment through its EngageCPW portal.

Vail Tribune